
Build a search-quality scorecard for your team
You'll have a working rubric (as a simple spreadsheet or text file) that your team can use to rate whether an AI search result is good enough for your specific use case—with 3-5 concrete criteria and
What you'll make
AI Search Quality Scorecard
- Scoring Criteria: 4-5 dimensions with definitions and examples
- Threshold Guide: when to use, verify, or reject results
- Edge Case Log: systematic failures your team has found
- Calibration Notes: where team members disagree and why
Share as a simple text file, spreadsheet, or document your team can reference during actual search tasks
The 4 parts
Each part ends with a check you can see.
Audit Your Current Search Decisions
Track how your team actually uses AI search results for one week and identify where quality matters most.
Done when
You have documented 15+ real search results your team used, with notes on what you trusted vs verified vs rejected.
Test Quality Boundaries
Define 4-5 specific quality criteria and test them against your collected examples to find the right thresholds.
Done when
You have 4-5 named criteria with clear definitions and tested thresholds that correctly classify 80%+ of your examples.
Document Systematic Failures
Find the edge cases where AI search consistently fails for your use case and build override rules.
Done when
You have documented 5+ specific failure patterns with examples and clear guidance on when human judgment must override the scorecard.
Build the Working Scorecard
Assemble your tested criteria, thresholds, and edge cases into a scorecard your team can actually use.
Done when
You have a complete scorecard document with 4-5 criteria, scoring guidance, edge case protocols, and instructions for keeping it updated.
Capstone: you put together your AI Search Quality Scorecard.
Where this helps
An elective: a single lesson that sits outside rtwo's job certificates and doesn't count toward one.
About this lesson
What you'll be able to do
- Create a working scorecard with 4-5 criteria your team actually uses to rate AI search results
- Test the scorecard on at least 10 real search results from your work and calibrate thresholds
- Document 3+ edge cases where your team's judgment overrides what an AI search tool suggests
- Have a repeatable process for updating the scorecard as AI search tools evolve
Who it's for
- Teams that use AI search tools for research, competitive intelligence, or customer support
- Anyone who needs to train others on when to trust vs verify AI search results
- People tired of inconsistent quality judgments across their team when using AI search
What it won't cover
- Building your own AI search system or technical implementation
- Optimizing search queries or prompt engineering techniques
- Comprehensive evaluation of different AI search platforms
- Legal or compliance frameworks for search result validation
Skills you'll practise
- Result quality assessment
- Edge case enumeration
- Team calibration
- Scorecard iteration